What is Chargeback Fraud?
Chargeback fraud is the intentional misuse of the chargeback process to fraudulently reverse a legitimate payment transaction. The fraudster makes a purchase, receives the goods or services, then contacts their bank to dispute the charge and receive a refund — effectively getting the product for free.
How Chargeback Fraud Works
The fraudster follows a deliberate process:
- Makes a legitimate purchase using their own card
- Receives the product or service
- Contacts their bank claiming the transaction was unauthorised, the product was not received, or the product was significantly different from what was described
- The bank initiates a chargeback, reversing the payment
- The fraudster keeps the product and receives a refund
Types of Chargeback Fraud
- Never received: Claiming the product was not delivered when it was
- Not as described: Claiming the product was significantly different from the description
- Unauthorised transaction: Claiming they did not make the purchase
- Subscription trap: Using free trials with the intention of disputing any charges
Impact on Businesses
Beyond losing the product and the payment, businesses face chargeback fees, potential fines from card brands, higher processing rates, and risk of merchant account termination if chargeback rates exceed thresholds (typically 1% of transactions).
Fighting Chargeback Fraud
Merchants can contest fraudulent chargebacks through the representment process — providing evidence that the transaction was legitimate. Success depends on having strong documentation: delivery tracking, customer communications, transaction logs, and call recordings.
Paytia helps businesses fight chargeback fraud by maintaining comprehensive transaction records. Every phone payment processed through Paytia's secure platform includes detailed audit trails. Because DTMF suppression allows continuous call recording with no gaps, businesses have clear audio evidence of the customer agreeing to the payment, which strengthens chargeback representment cases.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the chargeback rate threshold?
Card brands typically flag merchants with chargeback rates above 1% of transactions. Visa's threshold is 0.9% and 100 chargebacks per month. Exceeding these limits can result in monitoring programmes, fines, and potentially losing the ability to accept cards.
How do I dispute a fraudulent chargeback?
Submit a representment package to your acquiring bank within the deadline (usually 30 days). Include transaction evidence, delivery confirmation, customer communications, and any call recordings. Your payment processor or chargeback management service can help prepare the case.
Can call recordings help with chargeback disputes?
Yes, significantly. A call recording showing the customer verbally confirming the purchase, agreeing to the price, and providing their card details is strong evidence in a chargeback dispute. DTMF masking ensures the recording captures the conversation without the card data.
See how Paytia handles chargeback fraud
Book a personalised demo and we'll show you how our platform works with your setup.
Request a Demo